HOME | TACKLETOUR FORUMS  | EDITOR'S CHOICE | REVIEW ARCHIVE | ABOUT US | 

Latest ArticlesReels | Rods | Lines | Lures | Terminal Tackle | Tools | Storage | Watercraft | Apparel | Electronics | Enthusiast | Interviews | Events | Maintenance | Autopsy

Hot Articles


Complete ICAST 2017 Coverage
---------------

TackleTour Exclusive: On the Water with the New G.Loomis Conquest Rod Series

 ---------------

Ready to Combat the USDM : Evergreen International's Jack Hammer
---------------
First Look Inside the New Shimano Curado K Series Baitcasters
---------------

An Easier to Fish Schooling Bait - The PDL Rig
 


 


Product Shootout


TT Shootout : Zillion TWS vs Chronarch CI4+ (continued)

 

Pitching: For the pitching tests, I tied on a 3/8th ounce jig from Bass Patrol and once again found that after about a dozen pitches with each reel, distance was roughly the same. The interesting observation here was that at times it felt as though the Zillion TWS could pitch further, but that the pitch was choked of at the end by the magnetic brakes. Oddly enough when I backed off the brakes entirely, pitching distance didn't improve by much but that choked off sensation no longer presented itself.


The Zillion TWS line guide lets the line come off the reel's spool effortlessly during a pitch.

To be sure we were making an apples to apples comparison, I backed off all brakes on the Chronarch CI4+ as well and also found out pitching distance was more or less the same as when the brakes were on. For both reels, pitching is such a low spool speed presentation, the spool probably doesn't spin up fast enough for a long enough period of time for the casting brakes to have any real effect. Advantage : DRAW


But the Chronarch CI4+ was no slouch either. Result? A draw.

Low End Casting Limit: The last casting test we made with these reels was to see how light of a bait they'd let us cast. Three eighths (3/8ths) of an ounce is the lower end rating for the Megabass F6-72X4 Destruction, so we switched these reels over to identical Phenix Recon PHX-C682 instead to test out their lower limits. During each of the reels' individual product reviews, I got a sense they'd be able to handle baits down to one quarter of an ounce, but I never really investigated further.

 


To test each reel's low end casting limit, we went all the way down to a lure and hook combo that topped our scale at 5 grams.

 

Thanks to this shootout assignment, I took the time to find that proper stick with which to pair these rods and test this limit. To the end of each line, I tied a bare Owner #2 Wacky Hook and attached the new Savage Gear 3" 3D Craw. Total weight of the hook and bait was 5 grams or 0.176 ounces.

 


The Chronarch CI4+ just edged the Zillion TWS.

 

A few test casts with each combo in order to fine tune their brake adjustments and I found the Chronarch CI4+ just ever so slightly edged out the Zillion TWS in distance with this bait (roughly fifty feet to forty five feet). I did not get the sense either reel could realistically go lower in weight than the unweighted 3D Craw. On the plus side for the Zillion TWS, it was easier to fine tune its brakes because there was only one setting to adjust, but given the performance difference with the Chronarch CI4+, taking the extra steps necessary to adjust its brakes was worth it. Advantage : SHIMANO


Fig 1: This chart illustrates the sweet drag performance of our Zillion TWS.

Max Drag: The Zillion TWS measured out in our lab with a massive 18.7 pounds of maximum pressure. The Chronarch CI4+ came in with a more than respectable 10 pounds of maximum pressure, but if pure lockdown, drag them out, heavy drag power is what you're after, the Zillion TWS wins this category hands down. Advantage : DAIWA


Fig
2: This chart illustrates the sweet drag performance of our Chronarch CI4+.

Sweet Drag: The Sweet Drag Performance charts for both these reels both show curves that are very smooth and consistent except during lockdown where the Chronarch CI4+'s curve was just slightly less erratic. Similarly in their overall numbers, the Chronarch CI4+ just edges out the Zillion TWS in terms of average change in drag pressure when measuring startup drag versus sustained, and the largest drop in drag pressure from sustained. The differences are slight, but the Chronarch CI4+ has the sweeter sweet drag numbers. Advantage : SHIMANO

 

Drag Specifications

 
Daiwa Zillion TWS
Shimano Chronarch CI4+
Max Drag
18.7
10
Change in Startup vs Sustained (avg)
3.91%

3.33%

Biggest Drop from Sustained (avg)
14.4%
12%


With four available retrieve ratios including super low (5.5:1) and super high (9.1:1), the Zillion TWS as a suite of reels offers more versatility than that of the Chronarch CI4+.

Next Section: Retrieve Ratios and Versatility

 

 

 

Google
  Web
  TackleTour

 

 

 
 





 

 



Copyright 2000-2017 TackleTour LLC All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy information.